A Reality Check on Harm Reduction

Here in the San Francisco Bay Area injection drug use, primarily heroin, and the associated health problems have been major public health issues for decades. In response public health advocates in the Bay Area and beyond have implemented needle exchange programs in which injection drug users can obtain, oftentimes for free, syringes and related paraphernalia generally in exchange for an equal number of dirty needles. The main aims are to reduce needle sharing which leads to the spread of diseases such as HIV and Hep C as well as curbing the danger of discarded needles in public. Other services such as HIV testing and free condoms are also often available. Despite ideological and political opposition the effectiveness of these programs has since been validation by US and international research. Going a step farther than needle exchange are Supervised Injection Sites (SIS) where drug users can obtain clean needles as well as inject onsite with medical staff present in case of overdose. Clients can also gain access through such programs to counseling, drug treatment, and other services. This model, however, has yet to catch on in North America, with the only exception being Insite in Vancouver.

Science-based medicine and health policy are part of my primary interests in skepticism and so I’ve been disappointed by a lack of discussion of the claims for and against such harm reduction programs which offer a more compassionate and more science-based approach to the social and individual problems of substance dependence than criminalization of users. Interested in getting another point of view I left a voice message with the crew over at my favorite Canadian podcast, The Reality Check. In their latest episode the crew brings on Dina Tsirlin, who has done public health research in this area, to answer my questions. So give it a listen!

Further Resources:

TRC #267: Supervised Injection Sites + Who Owns The Future + Are Refrigerators Death Traps?

My Congressman by Fifteen (One of the greatest punk songs)

Insight Evaluation Finding

UHRI – Insight Report

Vancouver Coastal Health – Report on Supervised Injection Sites

2 Responses to “A Reality Check on Harm Reduction”

  1. M Simon Says:

    “Addiction” is not a helpful word. Try this: “People in chronic pain chronically take pain relievers.” Beginning to make sense? Add in that the pain is mostly PTSD. Look up the work of Dr. Lonny Shavelson for more clues.

  2. M Simon Says:

    I forgot to subscribe to your site.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 292 other followers

%d bloggers like this: